The Jewish Leadership Movement -- Manhigut Yehudit
   

Manhigut Yehudit

The Jewish Leadership Movement
 

Authentic Jewish Leadership For Israel

What's New?

Weekly Update Web Blog Donate Contact Us
 
New Page 1 New Page 1 New Page 1 Note
 

The Site Menu is Loading

Please Be Patient

If the menu does not appear within 30 seconds then:


Click here to find out why & how to solve this problem

 

Our Views

Patty Hearst Makes Aliyah
Founder and President, Manhigut Yehudit
Elul
5765 (Sept 05)

Patty Hearst was the granddaughter of millionaire media tycoon, Randolph Hearst. In 1974 she was kidnapped by an extreme left organization, the SLA. They demanded six million dollars for her release. The Hearst family paid the ransom, but Patty didn't come home.

After an analysis of this week's Likud Central Committee vote, in which Sharon succeeded in fending off an attempt to oust him, I was reminded of the Patty Hearst story, which psychologists have named the "Patty Hearst Syndrome". Patty Hearst didn't come home -- not because her kidnappers didn't keep their end of the deal. She didn't come home because she chose to join them.

The Israeli Patty Hearst Syndrome doesn't begin with Ariel Sharon and the disengagement. It begins immediately after the Six Day War. The national unity government of Eshkol and Begin didn't really know what to do with the expanses of the Land of Israel that had fallen so unexpectedly into its hands. The general public was enthralled with the new, yet familiar Biblical landscapes. Eric Lavi composed a hit song, "See, Mother Rachel, your children have returned to their Land," and the first movement advocating our rights in the entire Land of Israel was started by authors, poets and intellectuals -- all from the Labor party. They were the left wing of that era.

But the great emotional outpouring did not translate into Israeli sovereignty over the newly liberated homeland. Instead, the subsequent leftist governments quietly allowed Gush Emunim to build new settlements. These governments even initiated some of the settlements.

But the extreme left of those days did not just sit quietly. Although it never represented the Jewish majority in Israel, it was always much better than the right at taking control of the country's power bases, thus compensating for its small numbers. By the time of the Oslo Accords, the extreme left already controlled all the power bases in Israel's cultural and media establishments, the court system, the economy and security. When Rabin shook Arafat's hand, Israelis -- and the rest of the world -- were astonished. But in reality this was just the unveiling of Israel's new political face after the extreme left had totally overpowered the consciousness of the much more centrist Zionistic left.

At first glance, it seems that this new situation created a balance of power -- the "peace" camp against the national camp. But this balance was strictly political. The "peace" camp had all the power in its hands, and it knew how to use it. The national camp found itself eternally on the defensive. The right wing politicians caught on quickly, and understood where the carrot and where the stick were positioned in the Israeli reality. They learned where to turn to get positive media coverage, against whom criminal charges were investigated and which laws the Supreme Court tended to reject. True, it was easier to be elected as a representative of the right, as most of the voters were right wing. But in order to survive in politics, the politicians preferred to turn their backs on their voters and to insinuate to the left that they were willing to make a deal

Ariel Sharon was one of the strongest right wing politicians -- an ardent hawk. He even managed to hijack the entire arsenal of the left and to survive. At least that is what he thought. But it seems that at some point after the Lebanon war, Sharon understood that  he could not really overpower the left and the power bases behind it. When he finally became Prime Minister, Sharon decided to finish off his career as an adored victor. All that he had to do to achieve his goal was to join the strong people.

Sharon is our own home-grown Patty Hearst. He no longer has to fear police investigation and other pressures of the left, just as Patty no longer had to fear her kidnappers. Sharon simply internalized the left's ideology. Today he implements it with identification and faith in the righteousness of the left's goals.

Sharon's determined leadership justifiably garners admiration. But we must see his leadership qualities in their proper perspective. Sharon knows how to lord over the weak -- over the despised "lowlifes" (as Omri Sharon referred to them) of the Likud Central Committee, and over the naive settlers of Gush Katif. When it comes to dealing with the strong power bases -- the Israeli left and the Hamas - Sharon changes his tune. Then "self restraint is the true power."

As soon as he became prime minister, Sharon, backed by the power bases of the left, activated his new determined leadership. In no time he found himself directly opposed to his own voters, the people of the national camp. When he ignored the Likud member's referendum and the decisions of the Likud Central Committee, it seemed that his chances to be re-elected were very slim. But Sharon, himself a willing victim of the Patty Hearst Syndrome, understood how to turn his opponents into enthusiastic supporters. He understood that if he would consistently win, most of the public would be swayed to his side. After all, everybody likes to go with a winner.

Until the sensitive and determined pogrom in Gush Katif was actually perpetrated, a strong and frustrated national camp stood firmly against Sharon. As soon as the pogrom was successfully and easily carried out (with a little help from Sharon's friends within the settler camp) Sharon swept the entire national camp far into the reaches of the extreme left. The Likud, as an expression of the Jewish majority in Israel, and the Likud Central Committee as its representative, expressed this erosion in this week's vote. Likud Central Committee members, some obviously religious, danced ecstatically after the victory the man who led to the destruction of the synagogues of Gush Katif. Patty Hearst would have been proud.

This week, with the defeat of the faithful public at the Likud Central Committee, the extreme left completed its slow process of domination over Israeli society. They gained control over all the power bases in Israel without regard for who had won the elections. While the consciousness of the national camp had still remained essentially unfettered, Sharon has now put an end to that, as well. While before the disengagement it was still possible to wage a determined battle, the only option open to the faithful public after the disengagement is to protest. The conflict is no longer between the national camp and the left, but between the settler camp and the rest of the nation.

The implications of this analysis are difficult to digest. Many settlements are in immediate danger. It is almost impossible to oppose any further disengagement, as it has become the will of the majority.

But the orange public has a great and decisive advantage. Reality.

Ten years of bloodshed and economic plight brought the Israeli public out of the Oslo induced stupor and into the right-wing camp. The disengagement, (far more dangerous than Oslo) is liable to stir up terrible anti-Semitism in the world and to cause a bloodbath and economic hardships never before experienced in Israel.

For months, the Israeli media brainwashed the Israeli public with the Disengagement Festival. But in the process, the public was exposed to the one sector that it could really count on. The average Israeli sitting in front of his TV set saw idealistic people -- modest, willing to make sacrifices, children and their parents prepared to fight for their principles. Despite all the character assassination perpetrated against the settlers by the media, the image of the one sector to whom the Israeli public can turn when the current elites jump ship was seared deep into their unconscious.

It took ten years for Israel to snap out of Oslo. It is unclear how long it will take for us to snap out of the disengagement. But paradoxically, although Israel is trying so hard to eliminate the orange public, it is specifically this  public that is their only chance to survive. And they know it!

When the time comes the orange public will lead.

 

Print This Article
Click on the above link for a printer friendly version
of this article in PDF Format
Click here for help

 

 

The web site has been dedicated to the blessed memory of

Now it's time to hear you!
BLOG IN -- and voice your opinions!
jewishleadership.blogspot.com

Your Feedback is Important to Us
Click here to send us your comments
This web site is presented by:
 Manhigut Yehudit (The Jewish Leadership Movement)
© 5760 - 5766 (2000 - 2005) All rights reserved

Contact us at : office@jewishisrael.org

This website has been dedicated to the beloved memory of
Yehudit Chaya bas Sarah and Label Bloom

To dedicate our website in honor or memory of a loved one email: office@manhigut.org

You can turn the State of Jews into the Jewish State.
Now is the Time!
Join Manhigut Yehudit Today
Joining Manhigut Yehudit is much more than just a donation.
Now you're part of the team!
Learn about our special Members Club

Jewish Israel

Subscribe to Our
Email Newsletter

 

Check out our latest videos:
Campaign 2007
Israel: World Recycling Superpower

 

   Moshe Feiglin's
NEWEST Book:

The War of Dreams
available in English now!

Click here to order online now
 

Become a Member
or Donate

Join US
Now is the Time!

Joining Manhigut Yehudit is much more than just a donation.
Now you're part of the team!

 

Feiglin's Perspective


British Gas: A Deadly Deal
by Moshe Feiglin

 

Our Views


Pesach in Cancun, Greece or Los Vegas?
by Shmuel Sackett